Earth Hour is tokenistic nonsense

I am appalled at the way in which the large companies (and the ABC) have enthusiastically climbed upon the Bandwagon of Earth Hour. What? So the lights can get turned back on again, at 9:00pm on Saturday night? When they serve no purpose in being on.

It might look good as a "light show" for the Television and the Newspapers, but it is tokenistic, and a stunt.

It is good publicity for the marketing gurus of WWF, but they are flogging it as an ego trip for themselves (Earth Hour has "gone global"). It will do nothing for the planet. But it will do wonders for the CVs of the individuals in WWF.

Expect them to progress in Marketing, Advertising, and Politics and the other Trivial Arts of self-serving commercialism.

Denis Wilson

MURRAY DARLING DEAL DELIVERED

MY comment is two-fold.

A - It is a shame that the late Professor Peter Cullen did not live to see this eventuate.

B - Senator Penny Wong is a good Minister, and a very good South Australian Senator. That latter point is highlighted throughout this statement, (and the outcome itself). That is not a criticism - far from it. I think she has done an excellent job in bringing some sanity the Murray River deal, including the "buy-back" of water for environmental flows in the Murray River.

Denis Wilson

Robertson NSW 2577

*******************************************************

Senator Penny Wong's Press Release 26 March 2008

MURRAY DARLING DEAL DELIVERED

Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and First Ministers from across the Murray Darling Basin today forged an historic deal for the future of the Basin, ending a year long stalemate between the States and the Commonwealth and over a decade of inaction.

In Adelaide for the first COAG meeting of the year, all parties agreed to a new approach to drive reform in securing water for households, farmers and the long-term health of the Murray Darling Basin.

The deal includes:

• The establishment of the independent Murray Darling Basin Authority as the single body responsible for the overarching management of the Basin;
  
• Arrangements giving the Commonwealth Minister power to approve a new Basin-wide plan, including a new cap on the amount of water used in the Basin, based on independent advice from the Authority;
  
• A commitment to provide for critical human needs and arrangements to allow South Australia to store water in upstream dams to ensure there's enough water for Adelaide and towns reliant on the Murray for drinking water;
  
• Continuation of the States role in setting annual water allocations, decisions on natural resource management across the Basin and a new role to provide input to the Basin-wide plan;
  
• An in-principle commitment from the Commonwealth to invest up to $1 billion in Stage 2 of the Foodbowl Project in Victoria to return 100 billion litres of water to the Murray River and an equivalent volume of water to farmers in the Goulburn region; and
  
• Adoption of new reform outcomes and investment priorities for Commonwealth spending in the Murray Darling Basin.
  

The deal follows lengthy negotiations between the Commonwealth and Victoria.

Minster for Climate Change and Water, Senator Wong will now progress work with stakeholders on the implementation of this agreement.

COAG agreed in 1994 to a range of reforms across the Murray Darling Basin, but implementation of these reforms has been too slow and the River Murray has continued to decline.

"The Murray Darling Basin has been "Centre Court" for the Blame Game over the past decade," Senator Wong said.

Flows to rivers across the Basin have been below average for the past eleven years, with the past two years in the southern basin the worst on record.

"We've already taken immediate action in the area of purchasing water to put back in the River since forming government, but the problems in the Murray Darling Basin need a long term solution," Senator Wong said.

"Today we've laid the foundations for the long term future of the Murray Darling Basin and delivered on our election commitment to deliver for the Basin."

Establishing the new Murray Darling Basin Authority (MDBA)

Following good progress at the last Murray Darling Basin Ministerial Council meeting earlier this month, First Ministers have agreed to bring the Murray Darling Basin Authority together with the existing Murray Darling Basin Commission.

"The delivers a key election commitment of our Government to ensure there is a single body responsible for the oversight of the Murray Darling Basin."

The independent authority will be responsible for developing the new Basin-wide plan.

The States have agreed that the Commonwealth Minister will approve the Basin-wide plan, including a new cap on the amount of water that can be taken from the rivers and groundwater systems of the Basin based on the independent advice of the Authority.

Unlike the arrangements put forward by Malcolm Turnbull last year, the governance arrangements for the new Authority will take account for the need to continue to work closely with the States by ensuring they are consulted on the Basin-wide plan.

"We recognise that a cooperative approach is in the best interests of the communities, farmers and natural environment of the Basin."

The States will also retain a decision making role through a new Ministerial Council in relation to existing functions that will be moved from the Murray Darling Basin Commission into the new Authority.

Critical human needs

A key agreement from today's meeting is to provide for critical human needs in the overarching Basin Plan to be developed by the new Murray Darling Basin Authority.

This addresses a key fault in the previous government's failed plan, which did not address the important issue of drinking water supplies in the Basin.

"Here in Adelaide, people understand that a plan for the future of the Murray Darling Basin has to address the needs of people who rely on the River for their drinking water."

In addition, South Australia will be able to store water in Hume Dam and Dartmouth Dam which will give South Australia better flexibility to manage its share of the Murray to meet the needs of Adelaide households.

Fast-tracking infrastructure investment – Stage 2 Foodbowl Project

Inline with our election commitment to accelerate investment in the Murray Darling Basin, the Commonwealth has given in-principle support to provide up to $1 billion to Stage 2 of the Foodbowl Project in Victoria, subject to due diligence.

The previous government did not invest a single dollar in infrastructure under their National Plan for Water Security announced in January 2007.

Stage 2 of the Foodbowl Project is expected to return approximately 100 billion litres to the Murray River, with an equivalent amount of water to be provided to farmers in the Goulburn area of Victoria.

Subject to due diligence, the project would commence in 2009/10.

"Stage 1 of the Foodbowl Project is already well progressed and forms a key plank of Victoria's water plan," Senator Wong said.

"I'm looking forward to the opportunity to work with Victoria on due diligence for this project."

Reform and Investment priorities across the Basin

Unlike the previous government, we have worked with the States to identify high level reform objectives and investment priorities to drive how the Commonwealth will deliver investment in the Basin under the $10 billion plan.

"The previous government sought a blanket referral of powers and were unsuccessful in getting support for their plan,"

"What we've done is to work with the States to identify how we can start to amend the damage caused by years of neglect."

Today's agreement will be formalised through an Intergovernmental Agreement to be provided at the July 2008 COAG meeting.

On top of implementing this new approach for the Basin, the Commonwealth will continue to purchase water from willing sellers as part of the $50 million buy-back announced in February this year. This buy-back is the first time the Australian Government has ever directly purchased water for the environment.

End of Senator Wong's Press Release.